The Comforted Kitty Reviews

Natalie Tereshchenko 2025.11.30

     

In short: We really enjoyed our experience with The Comforted Kitty! The longer story: I'd been dragging my feet on finding a new sitter for our cat ever since our previous sitter moved away. After reading through reviews, we decided to give The Comforted Kitty a try, and I'm so grateful we did! Daniel took wonderful care not only of our furry son but also of our home. He followed all our instructions to a T and sent thoughtful updates throughout our trip. The website is easy to navigate and made the whole process feel professional and trustworthy. We highly recommend The Comforted Kitty and will definitely use their services again!

Useful Report

Reply from The Comforted Kitty 2025.12.06

We are so happy to hear of your great experience with our company. We are proud to have amazing cat sitters like Daniel on our team and glad to hear he made you feel at ease and that you would choose us again. We appreciate your trust in The Comforted Kitty.

Karla Ly 2025.11.21

     

I've been using Comforted Kitty for almost a year now ever since I moved to the San Francisco Bay Area. Serenity was / currently is our cat sitter and she goes above and beyond whenever she stops by. She is so attentive and caring to my kitties, and keeps the my home up and running when I'm gone. She is super neat & tidy, and when I come back home I find my apartment in a better state than when I left it! She truly is the sweetest and I enjoy having her as my sitter! Booking is also quick and effortless on the website, and the staff is really responsive and willing to help you out if you need anything.

Useful Report

Reply from The Comforted Kitty 2025.11.23

Thanks for trusting us and continuing to let us serve your kitties! We are proud to have caring and thoughtful cat sitters like Serenity on our team and happy to hear that she provides great care for your kitties and your home.

david scheinker 2025.11.17

     

Fantastic, seamless experience - The app took care of everything, including reminders and updates. The sitter we had, Stephanie, was fantastic and professional. She came to our house ahead of time, took notes and made sure she knew everything was and how we wanted her to do things. I’m going to use them again!

Useful Report

Reply from The Comforted Kitty 2025.11.23

Thank you so much for choosing us and sharing your great experience. So happy Stephanie made you feel at ease and that you would choose us again.

Lauren Magee 2025.11.16

     

My experience with The Comforted Kitty was great! We were away on a trip for a little over a week and Anita was amazing with our two cats! The whole process was very thorough, including filling out forms and having a meet and greet with the sitter before hand. Anita kept us updated with daily reports, pictures, and videos! There happened to be a day when our electronic door lock’s battery died and she called us right away so we were able to get it resolved and she was able to get in and calm our cats down. We will definitely be using The Comforted Kitty again!

Useful Report

Reply from The Comforted Kitty 2025.11.16

Thanks so much for choosing us and for sharing your review! We are proud to have professional cat sitters like Anita and happy to hear she provided dependable care for your kitties. We appreciate your trust in our company and look forward to serving you again soon.

Negeen Abrishamcar 2025.11.05

     

I love comforted kitty pet sitting!! I've been using their services for a few years now and I've always been matched with Emily. She is so great with my two cats and fantastic and providing updates. I'm always nervous to leave my cats, but she always makes me feel better about it.

Useful Report

Reply from The Comforted Kitty 2025.11.08

Thank you for your review and your continued trust in our company. We are proud to have dependable and caring cat sitters like Emily on our team and happy to hear she provides peace of mind for you when you are away. We look forward to serving you again soon.

Sophie L 2025.11.04

     

We cannot recommend Genna and the comforted kitties highly enough! She has looked after our two cats several times now, and every experience has been fantastic. Genna keeps us updated every day with lovely photos and videos, which gives us complete peace of mind while we are away. It is clear that she genuinely cares for our cats, they are always happy, relaxed, and well looked after when we get home. We feel so lucky to have found her and will definitely be using her services again. Thank you

Useful Report

Reply from The Comforted Kitty 2025.11.08

Thank you so much for your continued business and trust in our company. We are so happy to hear our amazing cat sitter Genna has provided you with peace of mind when you are away. We look forward to serving you and your cats again soon.

Pat Williams 2025.11.02

     

This is the first time we've used a pet sitting service and we were so very pleased with Stephan's care and obvious love for his "kids." He provided wonderful twice daily updates as well as photos and videos of our boys. We can highly recommend Stephan and the Comforted Kitty!

Useful Report

Reply from The Comforted Kitty 2025.11.08

We are glad you found us and appreciate your trust in our company. We are proud to have caring and dependable sitters like Stephan on our team and happy to hear he took great care of your kitties. We look forward to serving you again soon.

June OBrien 2025.10.31

     

I have used this pet sitting company now for 2 years whenever I’m out of town and need someone to come take care of my cats for a few days. Both sitters they have sent have been amazing and my cats love them. Every day they send me pictures and updates on how my cats are doing. If you’re looking for a great pet sitter I’d definitely recommend this company!

Useful Report

Reply from The Comforted Kitty 2025.10.31

We are honored to be the company to meet your cat care expectations! We are so happy to hear our professional cat sitters have provided great care for your cats. Thank you for your trust in our company and we look forward to serving you and your cats again soon.

Lauryn Beth 2025.10.25

     

I reached out to The Comforted Kitty for a sitter during a short trip and was paired with Jacki—she was wonderful! From the start, her communication was excellent, she arrived on time for our meet and greet, and she kept me updated every day while I was away. The daily photos she sent truly put my mind at ease and made me smile. It was the longest I’d ever been away from my cat, but I felt completely comforted knowing he was being loved and cared for. I’ll definitely use The Comforted Kitty again—especially Jacki! Easy 5 stars :)

Useful Report

Reply from The Comforted Kitty 2025.10.25

We are so happy you found us and thank you for the great review! We are proud to have Jacki on our team and happy to hear that she provided you with peace of mind while you were away. We look forward to serving you again soon and appreciate your trust in our company.

Arthur Patrick Brophy 2025.10.14

     

I've used this service twice now and had the same sitter (Victor) both times - each was a great experience. The first time he came he was very attentive when learning my lil guy's routine, taking notes and learning where everything was. The pictures he sent while I was away gave me peace of mind that all was OK back home. It's great to know this service exists as I wouldn't be able to travel for work without it. Comforted Kitty stood out from the other services due to it's more personal and cat-specific team. It's a bit more expensive than other services but I'd rather pay more for a tailored experience provided by other cat lovers than any ole dog walker trying to care for my buddy :) I'm already planning my next trip and will absolutely use the service again.

Useful Report

Reply from The Comforted Kitty 2025.10.17

Thanks for the great review. We are honored to be the company to meet your cat care expectations. So happy Victor made you feel at ease and that you would choose us again.

Randy Paylor 2025.10.13

     

Excellent drop-in service from my sitter Lori. I was gone for a week and she took great care of my cat and was flexible when I had to leave early and add a day.

Useful Report

Reply from The Comforted Kitty 2025.10.17

Thank you for the review. We are happy to hear Lori provided excellent service for your cat. We appreciate your trust in our company and look forward to serving you again soon.

Joanna DeMarco 2025.10.13

     

We can’t say enough wonderful things about Stephan & The Comforted Kitty Cat Sitting company! He was absolutely fantastic in taking care of our cat, Jaxxie. He was always timely, attentive, and genuinely caring, spending quality time with her, feeding her, brushing her, washing her bowls, monitoring her stool, and keeping her litter box clean. Stephan even went above and beyond by working an extra day to make sure Jaxxie was cared for when we had to extend our flight due to a medical emergency. His dedication and professionalism gave us complete peace of mind while we were away. We highly recommend Stephan & The Comforted Kitty Cat Sitting and will definitely be requesting him anytime we go on vacation in the future. Thank you, Stephan, for being so amazing!

Useful Report

Reply from The Comforted Kitty 2025.10.17

Thanks for sharing your great experience with us! We are so proud of our caring and thoughtful cat sitters and happy to hear Stephan went above and beyond for you and Jaxxie. We appreciate your trust in our company and look forward to serving you again.

Kim Gorter 2025.10.12

     

This was my first experience using a cat sitter so I didn't know what to expect. My first impression was the website and how easy it was to navigate--always a good sign! After I signed up and picked my travel dates, the rest of the process ran efficiently and professionally. I loved that I was able to meet my 'sitter' before I left and Katana warmed to her immediately. My sitter L, sent me daily updates with pictures and I could tell Katana was not stressed at all. Overall it was an excellent experience and I will definitely be using Comforted Kitty in the future!

Useful Report

Reply from The Comforted Kitty 2025.10.17

Thank you so much for choosing us and sharing your great experience with us. So happy our professional cat sitter L made you feel at ease and that you would choose us again.

Aaron Bialick 2025.10.11

     

In my first experience with The Comforted Kitty, Natalie was a fantastic sitter for my cat George during my 11-day trip. She provided thorough daily reports with photos and videos that went above and beyond what I expected. And from what I could tell, she followed my instructions for feeding (with a ratioed prescription diet), replenishing water, cleaning litter, petting, etc. Would happily use them again!

Useful Report

Reply from The Comforted Kitty 2025.10.11

Thank you so much for choosing us and sharing your great experience. So happy to hear our amazing cat sitter Natalie provided thoughtful and dependable care for George and made you feel at ease. We appreciate your trust in us.

Chelsey 2025.10.09

     

The last 5 or 6 times we've traveled out of state, we've chosen The Comforted Kitty as our trusted cat sitter and have been fortunate to get Thad the last few visits. Thad is great with our cats, sends us photos everyday, and is very communicative about each visit. When I'm away from home I trust Thad and The Comforted Kitty to take the best care of my babies

Useful Report

Reply from The Comforted Kitty 2025.10.11

Thanks for the great review Chelsey. We appreciate your business and trust in us. We are proud to have Thad on our team and happy to hear provides quality care for your kitties.

Santiago Reina 2025.10.08

     

We had Marisa Q. as our sitter for a long two week trip to Asia! She was both wonderful with our kitties, and also consistent and professional. She communicated well and followed all instructions. Furthermore, she never made assumptions regarding cat treats, taking her time to read and remember the written notes and instructions thoroughly! Cannot be grateful enough for Comforted Kitty and Marisa!

Useful Report

Reply from The Comforted Kitty 2025.10.11

Thank you so much for choosing us and for the great review! We are happy to hear our professional cat sitter Marisa provided exceptional care for your kitties. We appreciate your trust in our company and look forward to serving you again.

Jo Calderon 2025.10.02

     

Used merchandise not new Sent used items ~ packaging horrific~ poor customer service

Date of experience: 26 September, 2025

Useful Report

E. 2025.09.23

     

cannot recommend the comforted kitty enough. i'm an anxious cat owner, spend a lot of time with my cats at home, and have developed routines for them based on their preferences (they're spoiled!). i've tried lots of sitters from other services and while they've been okay (just okay), i hadn't found anyone who i was really happy with until trying the comforted kitty. Eliška was my sitter and she took careful notes and was super responsive and for the first time, i had no anxiety during my time away - she answered all my questions before i even had to ask, she included little notes and observations that let me know the cats were comfy with her, and all of my instructions were followed to the letter. it was literally a perfect sit, i couldn't ask for anything more.

Useful Report

Reply from The Comforted Kitty 2025.09.26

Thank you so much for choosing us and for sharing your great review! We are happy to hear our professional cat sitter Eliska provided your cats with thoughtful and dependable care. We appreciate your trust in our company and look forward to serving you again.

Don Pham 2025.09.18

     

Sheena did a wonderful job of pet sitting our cat while we were on vacation. We felt relieved knowing that our cat was in good hands, and we loved the daily updates and photos after each visit. Sheena was very responsive during all communications, reliable, and very friendly. Thank you so much again!

Useful Report

Reply from The Comforted Kitty 2025.09.20

Thank you for the great review. We are glad to hear our professional cat sitter Sheena provided your cat with dependable care. We appreciate your trust in our company.

Jessica Lee 2025.09.17

     

So grateful for Reem who has looked after my cat twice now. My cat is a cuddle bug but also happens to be very shy, and Reem was incredibly sweet and patient with her. Reem was so great at meeting her at her level (literally, since my cat's favorite hiding spot is under the bed) to show her love and give her treats. The daily video updates were so lovely for when I was missing my little buddy. I appreciated how thorough the registration questionnaire was, and booking is really convenient. I highly recommend Reem and Comforted Kitty.

Useful Report

Reply from The Comforted Kitty 2025.09.20

Thank you so much for sharing your review with us. We are proud of the amazing cat sitters like Reem on our team and happy to hear we could provide you with dependable and thoughtful care for your cat while you were away.